This site has been archived and you can no longer log in or post new messages. For up-to-date community resources please visit ezplatform.com

eZ Community » Forums » Install & configuration » Impressions of ezp3 after 3 days of...
expandshrink

Impressions of ezp3 after 3 days of testing ...

Impressions of ezp3 after 3 days of testing ...

Tuesday 28 January 2003 1:02:54 am

1. I tested with register_globals off and all worked fine. This is a remarkable security improvement in ezp3. Thanks a lot.

2. I took some time to become familiar with the new object model. No doubt, the redundancies of ezp2 have been eroded with great rigor. This is appealing. However, I think in one case the goal to achieve an object model as compact as possible has been driven a step too far: In the treatment of users and user groups as instances of "CONTENT". User accounts and user groups, having "draft" and "publishing" state buttons assigned to them on the admin console, are a funny thing in first stance, but irritating and annoying in the long run. I recommend to review this. I further think there should be no direct assignment of roles to individual user accounts. Instead I suggest to replace the still too UNIX-like concept of a "User Group" with an object pattern "User Profile". Instances of "User Profile" should then become the only entities carrying role assignments. And there should be a n:1-relation between users and such profiles. So we get back what we can do with a "user group", just by assigning the same pattern of roles (now as a permission profile) to a multitude of users. And what else should we need "groups" for, if not to attach or detach individual user accounts to (from) permission patterns ?

3. The new template engine is a powerful, but also a heavyweight tool. For people like me - familiar with the template rendering model of ezp2 - it's a major paradigm shift to swallow. Oops. For people familiar with putting tiny php-snippets into HTML-pages it looks like "yet another proprietary scripting language on top of php." Most of all i hope it becomes no serious obstacle for future approaches to strengthen the role of XSLT in rendering. Concerns like this have already been reported in this forum and I do share them. However, the template engine is a tool with thorough and intelligent design. It's much faster than the former template utility and suitably stable yet, as far as I see. So it's hard for me to find out whether I love it or not.

4. I still don't know how to customize policies in the admin console.

Summary: I like ezp3 and will move my new site to this crazy tool. See the outcome within the next 10 days, if I have not fallen into dispair with templates by then blunk.gif Emoticon

Regards to you all out there.

Volker

No reply yet!

expandshrink

You must be logged in to post messages in this topic!

36 542 Users on board!

Forums menu

Proudly Developed with from